-
About
Our Story
back- Our Mission
- Our Leadership
- Accessibility
- Careers
- Diversity, Equity, Inclusion
- Learning Science
- Sustainability
Our Solutions
back
-
Community
Community
back
- Macmillan Community
- :
- Psychology Community
- :
- Psychology Blog
- :
- Cognitive dissonance, pandemic edition: Class disc...
Cognitive dissonance, pandemic edition: Class discussion
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark as New
- Mark as Read
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page
- Report Inappropriate Content
A lot of my Intro Psych students struggle with the concept of cognitive dissonance. If circumstances, say, a pandemic, provide an example of cognitive dissonance, and a couple social psychologists, say, Elliot Aronson and Carol Tavris, present the explanation, how could I not use it?
In their article in The Atlantic, Aronson and Tavris (2020) write:
Dissonance is most painful when evidence strikes at the heart of how we see ourselvesāwhen it threatens our belief that we are kind, ethical, competent, or smart. The minute we make any decisionāIāll buy this car; I will vote for this candidate; I think COVID-19 is serious; no, Iām sure it is a hoaxāwe will begin to justify the wisdom of our choice and find reasons to dismiss the alternative.
As a discussion (synchronous or asynchronous), present this scenario to your students.
*******************
Cognitive dissonance and COVID-19 discussion: Part I
Letās start with the premise that I believe that Iām the kind of person who makes smart decisions. I want to see my extended family and my friends; I should go out. But, dang, that virus is out there. It could make me very sick. Heck, it could kill me; I should stay home. I have cognitive dissonance between two thoughts.
Letās say that I go out to visit family and friends. Now I have cognitive dissonance between a behavior and a thought: Iām visiting with people but thatās clashing with knowing that this behavior could be dangerous.
Identify at least two things I could think or do that may reduce my dissonance.
*******************
Once students have offered their suggestions, such as saying āIām young and healthy, it probably wonāt affect me if I catch it,ā prompt with this follow-up.
*******************
Cognitive dissonance and COVID-19 discussion: Part II
While itās an easy way out of this particular cognitive dissonance, finding ways of justifying dangerous behavior is probably not the best solution. Aronson and Tavris (2020) write,
Although itās difficult, changing our minds is not impossible. The challenge is to find a way to live with uncertainty, make the most informed decisions we can, and modify them when the scientific evidence dictatesāas our leading researchers are already doing. Admitting we were wrong requires some self-reflectionāwhich involves living with the dissonance for a while rather than jumping immediately to a self-justification.
Maybe what we say to ourselves instead is, āYes, I usually make smart decisions, and I visited with people knowing that it may be dangerous to do so. While I can come up with a lengthy list of justifications, let me just sit with this for a while.ā
To not fall prey to cognitive dissonance we have to be able to identify the two dissonant thoughts/behaviors, and we have to be willing to stop and ask ourselves why we are doing/thinking what weāre doing/thinking. Aronson and Tavris (2020) encourage us to ask ourselves, āWhy am I believing this? Why am I behaving this way? Have I thought it through or am I simply taking a short cut, following the party lineā¦?ā
Choose one of the solutions offered in this discussion for how to reduce dissonance. For example, "I'm young and healthy, so I'm less likely to get sick."
Now, ask, "Why do I believe this?" "Because that's what friends keep saying"?
Next, evaluate the evidence. "It's true that those who are young and healthy are less likely to die, but young, healthy people can get very sick, and yes, they can die. Even if they have mild or no symptoms, they can still pass it on to others who could get very sick or die." Cite your reputable source, e.g., the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Reference
Aronson, E., & Tavris, C. (2020, July). The role of cognitive dissonance in the pandemic. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/07/role-cognitive-dissonance-pandemic/614074/
You must be a registered user to add a comment. If you've already registered, sign in. Otherwise, register and sign in.
-
Abnormal Psychology
19 -
Achievement
3 -
Affiliation
1 -
Behavior Genetics
2 -
Cognition
40 -
Consciousness
32 -
Current Events
26 -
Development Psychology
15 -
Developmental Psychology
34 -
Drugs
5 -
Emotion
48 -
Evolution
3 -
Evolutionary Psychology
5 -
Gender
19 -
Gender and Sexuality
5 -
Genetics
12 -
History and System of Psychology
5 -
History and Systems of Psychology
7 -
Industrial and Organizational Psychology
50 -
Intelligence
8 -
Learning
63 -
Memory
37 -
Motivation
14 -
Motivation: Hunger
1 -
Nature-Nurture
7 -
Neuroscience
42 -
Personality
27 -
Psychological Disorders and Their Treatment
19 -
Research Methods and Statistics
88 -
Sensation and Perception
43 -
Social Psychology
122 -
Stress and Health
55 -
Teaching and Learning Best Practices
50 -
Thinking and Language
16 -
Virtual Learning
26
- « Previous
- Next »